Developers Accused of Fueling Inflationary Fears Among Russians

Property analysts say buyers are being deliberately frightened with warnings of rising home prices

The Central Bank will have little reason to cut its key rate significantly, making market-rate mortgages more affordable, unless property developers stop stoking inflation expectations about housing prices among prospective buyers. By fuelling a sense of urgency among some families, they may also be benefiting themselves. This assessment of the housing market comes from property analysts, whose arguments have surprised some industry representatives. They contend that rising flat prices are more a consequence of broader inflationary pressures than a cause of inflation in their own right

The Central Bank’s decision to keep its key rate elevated at 14% a year for the second consecutive time has disappointed the property market, which is hoping for a return to cheaper mortgages

‘However, among the reasons why the regulator is reluctant to ease policy are the actions of the housing market itself,’ the Indicators of the Real Estate Market analytical centre (IRN) said in a review published on October 26 entitled ‘The Property Market Is Hindering a Key Rate Cut’.

‘Persistent scare stories about the inevitable rise in flat prices stimulate demand and push prices higher, fuelling inflation expectations among the public and reinforcing the Central Bank’s determination to keep rates high,’ the report’s authors warned

After examining recent statements by Central Bank Governor Elvira Nabiullina, IRN analysts described the mechanism at work: when people expect prices to rise soon, they act more quickly, making major purchases in an attempt to ‘save’ their money before it loses value. This boosts consumer demand, which in turn drives inflation higher.

‘It is a vicious circle: lowering the key rate requires low inflation, but low inflation requires subdued inflation expectations. Despite the Central Bank’s efforts, those expectations continue to rise. And they concern not only food and everyday goods, but also housing prices,’ the analysts explained.

Citing its online surveys of up to 1,000 respondents, IRN said the share of people expecting housing prices to rise over the next three months had increased from 31% in the summer to almost 47% in the autumn. Around 13% of respondents expected a substantial increase of more than 5%, compared with just 8% three months earlier

Some 27% of respondents now expect housing prices to fall, down from about 43% in the summer. Roughly a quarter are taking a wait-and-see approach, expecting prices to remain at current levels.

According to the report’s authors, no other consumer market sees industry participants promote the idea that their products are bound to become more expensive as persistently as the property sector does.

‘Food retailers and petrol sellers, if they raise prices, tend to do so quietly, using marketing tactics to disguise the increases. Estate agents and developers, by contrast, have turned the claim that housing prices must inevitably rise into an almost obsessive idea and their main selling point, thereby inflating inflation expectations,’ IRN argued.

The analysts also said that inflated expectations in the property market were sometimes created through misleading claims.

‘We are constantly bombarded with reports from every conceivable source saying that new-build prices are rising. But there is a great deal of disingenuousness here. Often, only the average price of new-build housing is increasing. Several years ago, the market included many affordable economy- and comfort-class developments. Today, it consists largely of expensive business- and premium-class properties.’

Developers Accused of Fueling Inflationary Fears Among Russians
Autumn 2025
Winter 2026
Spring 2026
Summer 2026
Autumn 2026
Prices will fall
Prices will rise
Prices will remain unchanged

Results of the survey ‘What Will Happen to Housing Prices?’, as a percentage of all respondents. Source: Indicators of the Real Estate Market analytical centre, IRN.RU.

This shift in the mix of properties explains the difference in average prices. In practice, some people who buy flats in new developments are unable to resell them even for the amount they originally paid

‘The property market has more to gain from a key rate cut than many other sectors. Yet through its own actions, artificially inflating expectations and constantly warning of rising housing prices, it is preventing that cut from happening,’ said Oleg Repchenko, head of IRN.

Industry representatives, however, have questioned the logic of this cause-and-effect argument

‘The property market is not, in itself, an inflationary factor. Rising flat prices are usually a consequence of inflationary pressures rather than their original cause. Higher prices for building materials, labour, logistics and maintenance all play a role. As construction costs rise, prices in the primary market are pushed up as well,’ Elena Chegodaeva, head of the NDV Supermarket of Real Estate department, told Nezavisimaya Gazeta

The information environment surrounding property is certainly mixed, Chegodaeva said. But recently, she added, prices in the primary market have almost stopped rising and have effectively stagnated

Nezavisimaya Gazeta asked industry experts to assess which party bears the greatest responsibility for keeping interest rates high: consumers and their inflation expectations, the property sector with its alarming predictions, the Central Bank and its uncompromising fight against inflation, or the government, which has introduced exceptionally broad subsidised mortgage programmes only to scale them back later.

‘It is government policy, primarily that of the Central Bank, that drives up borrowing costs, including mortgage rates and project financing. Commercial banks cannot operate at a loss, so they set lending rates in line with the key rate. Financial institutions also take account of the structure of the federal budget and the economic support measures proposed by the government,’ said Dmitry Proskurin, commercial director at Metrium.

In his view, developers and buyers in the primary housing market have relatively little influence on the trajectory of mortgage rates

High borrowing costs will persist even if the property market stops talking about rising housing prices, said Lilia Artsibasheva, commercial director at Regions Development. New-build housing and the mass-market subsidised mortgage programmes that operated until recently have undoubtedly contributed to overall inflation, she said, but they were not the main drivers of the process

Prices for new-build homes, particularly in Moscow, are now rising more slowly. The broad subsidised mortgage programme has been discontinued, while the family mortgage programme has been sharply curtailed. Yet inflation remains high, forcing the Central Bank to maintain a restrictive policy, Artsibasheva said

Kirill Agapov, chief executive of Umbrella Consulting Group, offered his own estimate of the relative contributions to the current situation, in which market mortgage rates remain elevated. He attributed around 35% of the impact to the side effects of government measures, 30% to Central Bank policy, 20% to the construction and property sectors and their rhetoric, and 15% to public concerns. He stressed that these figures were an expert assessment of relative influence, not a precise econometric calculation

Breaking the cycle requires a comprehensive approach. Notably, Agapov also agreed with criticism of forecasters who make excessively alarmist predictions.

Measures needed to restore the market to health include making subsidised mortgages more targeted, avoiding demand stimulus without a corresponding increase in supply, and reducing the circulation of forecasts predicting sharp price rises, he said. This would give the Central Bank more grounds for a sustained reduction in interest rates and make housing more affordable

ORIGINAL: NG/Developers Accused of Fueling Inflationary Fears Among Russians

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *